Leading Hatrick Takers 1896-2009
| Bowlers | Opposition | Venue | Date | |||
| M.W. Hatch (2) | v. | Synthonia | (away) | 11 | September | 1988 |
| v. | Normanby Hall | (away) | 25 | April | 1992 | |
| H. Turner (2) | v. | Bishop Auckland | (home) | 10 | June | 1922 |
| v. | Stockton | (home) | 18 | August | 1923 | |
| A.C. Williams (2) | v. | Guisborough | (home) | 15 | August | 1925 |
| v. | Darlington R.A. | (away) | 5 | September | 1925 | |
| P.A.D. Carey (1) | v. | Stockton | (home) | 3 | May | 1952 |
| N.A. Doggart (1) | v. | West Hartlepool | (away) | 17 | June | 1933 |
| J.B. Donald (1) | v. | West Hartlepool | (home) | 3 | September | 1960 |
| M.B.Foster (1) | v. | Saltburn | (home) | 24 | April | 1999 |
| A. Goodrick (1) | v. | Thornaby | (away) | 13 | August | 1921 |
| T.E. Gregory (1) | v. | Guisborough | (away) | 18 | June | 1910 |
| A. Johnson (1) | v. | Marske | (home) | 1 | July | 1972 |
| J.R.G. Lawrence (1) | v. | Markse | (home) | 15 | July | 1998 |
| F.R. Smith (1) | v. | Bishop Auckland | (home) | 7 | July | 1928 |
| W. Tolson (1) | v. | North Ormesby | (home) | 1 | September | 1906 |
| W.H. Wildsmith (1) | v. | Synthonia | (away) | 14 | June | 1941 |